The drama in the pianissimo

Our readings today are Lamentations 5 and Mark 15:42-16:8.

We’ve reached the last chapter of Lamentations. As Elizabeth noted on Tuesday, Lamentations is in the form of five poems in the form of a dirge — a funeral poem and lament for the dead. I’m no Hebrew scholar or poet, so while a quick search on the structure of Lamentations told me that the first four chapters use the Hebrew acrostic form of poetry, that’s pretty much lost on me, reading in English and trying to figure out what to make of it all.

What can be seen from the English though, is the progression of each poem, and the journey the grieving poet takes us on. I found a couple of overviews on helpful in getting my head around it (this one and this one). I particularly liked Homer Heater’s description of the dynamics of volume in the poetry, building through to a crescendo in chapter 3 and then getting softer again.

We move from the eye-witness account of the destruction of Jerusalem in chapter 1, through the realisation that God Himself is behind the destruction as punishment in chapter 2, to the well-known central pivot and focal point Chapter 3:22-24 as the crescendo:

Because of the Lord’s great love we are not consumed,
    for his compassions never fail.
They are new every morning;
    great is your faithfulness.
I say to myself, ‘The Lord is my portion;
    therefore I will wait for him.’

And having reached the peak, we then see the volume gradually turn down through chapter 4 as a general lament of sorrow.

And so we come to chapter 5, where I really appreciated thinking about lamentations from the perspective of the dynamics and volume in the poetry. Ground down by the oppression of slavery the poet’s final cries of lament seem faint, as though all the hope is gone from him.

Joy is gone from our hearts;
    our dancing has turned to mourning.
The crown has fallen from our head.
    Woe to us, for we have sinned!
Because of this our hearts are faint;
    because of these things our eyes grow dim
for Mount Zion, which lies desolate,
    with jackals prowling over it.


As any song leader knows, there is perhaps even more emphasis and more drama in the ppp pianissimo than the ƒƒƒ fortissimo. As the volume drops to a whisper, we read perhaps the greatest confession of the book—the almost horrified realisation that perhaps God has finally rejected Israel.

You, Lord, reign for ever;
    your throne endures from generation to generation.
Why do you always forget us?
    Why do you forsake us so long?
Restore us to yourself, Lord, that we may return;
    renew our days as of old
unless you have utterly rejected us
    and are angry with us beyond measure.


I suspect that’s how it would have felt at the end of Mark 15, as they buried Jesus in haste on preparation day. Has God utterly rejected us? What a long sabbath day must have filled the gap between the end of chapter 15 on Friday afternoon and the women going to the tomb at the start of chapter 16 on Sunday morning. I imagine this gap to be quieter still than that pianissimo in Lamentations 5. And yet that silence portends an even more profound truth to be unfolded.

I wonder if they made anything of the odd singling out of Peter, and the subtle rebuke in verse 7:

But go, tell his disciples and Peter, “He is going ahead of you into Galilee. There you will see him, just as he told you.”’

Ouch! Was Peter no longer one of the disciples after his denial of Jesus? Or was he singled out as the rock on which Christ would build his church? And there seems to be a bit of a poke in “Just as he told you”, referring to Mark 8:31, recorded by Mark just after Peter’s confession that Jesus was the Christ in Mark 8:27-30.

He then began to teach them that the Son of Man must suffer many things and be rejected by the elders, the chief priests and the teachers of the law, and that he must be killed and after three days rise again.

For me though, I think it’s the start of verse 8 that sums up the massive shift in world view that was about to take place, and that Mary, Mary and Salome were yet to comprehend. “Trembling and bewildered, the women went out and fled from the tomb”.

How would you make sense of what they have just experienced? We who know the ending might find it hard to fully appreciate how incomprehensible this must have been. These women were grieving and feeling, I would imagine, like the poet at the end of Lamentations, which you will recall is written in the form a dirge—a lament for the dead!

It would take some time for them to understand the profound truth that the silence between Friday and Sunday anticipated. That far from utterly rejecting us forever, God chose to reject His son in our place so that we might be restored.

God’s answer to all those cries for help in lamentations happens right there between Mark 15:42 and Mark 16:1 in that silence.




4 thoughts on “The drama in the pianissimo

  1. Thank you James. I think that the angel made special mention of Peter to show that in spite of Peters denials Jesus had not disowned or deserted him. He does the same for us today. When I sin and do the wrong thing Jesus doesn’t condemn or disown me. He wants to restore me back into fellowship. And because of the cross this is done in an instant. Peter was a broken man after denying Jesus but Jesus had a plan for Peter to fulfill in the church which was not yet in existence. (Bits from application study bible).

  2. Thanks James and Connie. I was struck this morning by the timing of the call to gather the people (sheep and disciples) of Christ, and not to forget those who may be or feel lost (Peter) as the first order of business following Christ’s resurrection.

    • This is where the ministry of the pew is so important. God has placed Peters in our church, sometimes they are sitting next to us. As we are in tune with the Holy Spirit He will direct us as to how to love and restore these hurting ones. He may have a word of wisdom for them or a word of knowledge. He may prompt us to offer to pray for healing for them. He knows what is needed for every individual, we just have to be willing and listen to His prompting then step out in faith and obey. There certainly is work to do right here in our own church, yet alone in this hurting world. No more holy huddles. May we ask God to lead us when we meet together tomorrow and watch Him do His work through us. After all we are supposed to be the hands and feet of Jesus. Lord give us eyes to see, ears open to hear You, and hearts that are willing to step out in faith and obey.

  3. Thank you James for your thoughtful, informative comment reminding us of the cost of our salvation and the depth of that price for For God himself.. Not to be taken lightly but with lament for our part .

Comments are closed.